Emmon Bodfish

Emmon Bodfish
(aka Margaret Ingalls Bodfish)

Location: Orinda, California
Cause of Death: Bludgeoned to death with a blunt object
Date of Death: June 24, 1999 (approximate)
Source: San Francisco Chronicle, July 1, 1999, and the Contra Costa Times, July 2, 1999
Notes: Emmon’s son, Maxwell Wills, was found dead from self-inflicted wounds in Santa Monica the day after Bodfish was discovered. The police, though, have all-but-ruled out Max in connection with Emmon’s death.


FTM Found Dead in Northern California

Emmon Bodfish, a reclusive female-to-male transperson, was found by police in their Orinda, California home on July 1st. Police are investigating the death as a homicide.

Mr. Bodfish’s body was discovered by police, who had been asked by another individual to check the home. They were discovered on the floor in the main part of the house. Police reports point to blunt force trauma as the cause of death, though the murder weapon has been determined. There were no signs of forcible entry, and while the house was in some disarray, the police were unsure if these were signs of struggle and/or ransacking, or just indicators of the upkeep of the house.

While the police have been reluctant to speak about the gender identity of the victim, neighbors have indicated that Bodfish had been living as a male and may have undergone some surgery. Initial reports on this case indicated that the coroner’s office was having difficulty determining the gender of the victim, though this may have had more to do with the decomposition of the body — which had been sitting in the home for “about a week” — rather than any other reason.

Bodfish, under their birth name of Margaret Ingalls Bodfish, purchased the home in Orinda, saying that it was for “her son,” Emmon. He also owned another residence in Mill Valley.

Anyone with information is urged to contact Sgt. Mark Hale at 925-313-2630, or Sgt. Chris Wenzel at 925-253-4250.

Charlie Goodyear of the San Francisco Chronicle contributed to this report.

Copyright 1999, Gwendolyn Ann Smith. Used with permission.


Do you have more information on this person that you would like to see here? If so, please write to gwen@gender.org, with a subject line of “remembering our dead.”

Return to the previous page